Here help you create personal & financial freedom

by helping you create a 6-figure+ online program

50 Sales Calls in 90 Days: What I Got Wrong, What I Got Right

50 Sales Calls in 90 Days: What I Got Wrong, What I Got Right

I teach sales calls, and I still botched a bunch of them. After 50 calls over the past several months, I went back through my transcripts and found five mistakes that were costing me clients (and a few were just cringey).

In this episode I walk through each one, what I say now instead, and the one that made the biggest difference in whether I closed the call.

Listen to the podcast here:

 


In this episode:

  • Why setting an intention at the start of a call puts people at ease and gets you permission to pitch
  • How much of the call you should be talking, and what happened on the calls where I went over 60 percent
  • How to get curious about objections instead of saying “just let me know”
  • Why to have your payment form open before the call, and what to do right after you say your price
  • How to set follow-up expectations so you keep control of the ball
  • The industry close rate for sales calls vs what my students close

 

Resources mentioned:

 


 

50 Sales Calls in 90 Days: What I Got Wrong and What I Got Right

I teach sales calls. I have a script for them. My students use that script and close somewhere between 50 and 60 percent of their calls, and a few have hit 90 percent (which is unicorn territory, but it happens).

So you would think I’d be immune to sales call mistakes. I am not.

Over the past several months I did 50 sales calls. When I went back through the transcripts, I caught myself making the exact mistakes I tell my students to avoid. Some of them cost me clients. Others were just cringey. One of them made a bigger difference to whether I closed a call than all the others combined.

This is the full breakdown of what I got wrong, what I got right, and what I do now on every call. If you are a coach or practitioner who sells programs or services through conversations, this will save you a lot of awkward calls and a lot of lost sales.

 


What 50 Sales Calls Showed Me About My Own Sales Process

Most of the people who get on a call with me have filled out an application, so I usually know a little about them before we talk. I record every call and review the transcripts afterward. That review is where the real learning happened.

Here is the number that matters. The industry standard close rate for sales calls is about 30 percent. If you learn a solid sales call structure and practice it, you can expect to close above that. My students regularly land between 50 and 60 percent. After 50 calls of my own, I can tell you that the way I teach sales calls is exactly what works. The calls that went sideways were the ones where I drifted away from my own structure.

Here are the five mistakes I found, in the order they show up on a call.

 


Mistake #1: Not Setting an Intention for the Sales Call

A sales call is a strange thing. You are meeting someone for the first time, neither of you knows quite what to expect, and the person on the other end may feel a bit vulnerable. For some people, this is the first time they have ever gotten on a call with a coach.

On two of my 50 calls, I forgot to set an intention. Those calls ended up erratic and all over the place. Every time I did set one, I could almost feel the energy change. Shoulders dropped. The person relaxed.

Start With Something Personal

I always open with something human before I get into business. If I have had prior interaction with the person, or I saw something on their application, I mention it. If we have something in common, I bring that up. If all else fails, I ask where they are in the world and what the weather is like. These are simple questions, but they take the awkwardness out of the first minute.

What to Say to Set the Intention

Once the small talk is done, I say something like this:

All right, Jane. This is what we’ll do today. What I’d love to do is have you tell me all about your business, what’s been going right, what’s been going wrong, and where you would like to see things go. I’ll listen to what you say, and if it feels like you’re someone I can help, we can talk a little more about working together inside HCA. Does that sound good?

That is the whole thing. It takes about 20 seconds.

Why Setting an Intention Works

There are three things happening in that short script.

  • You are telling the person exactly how the call is going to go, so there are no surprises and they can relax.
  • You are telling them you are going to pitch, so when you actually talk about your offer, they are expecting it because you already said it would happen.
  • You are asking for permission. When they say yes to “Does that sound good?”, they have given you permission to lead the call the way you laid it out, and permission to pitch. That makes pitching a lot less scary.

And if they say they thought this was a coaching call and they don’t want to hear about your program? Great. No problem. You say let’s not waste each other’s time and you hop off. That is a win for both of you.

 


Mistake #2: Doing Most of the Talking

This one made the biggest difference in whether I closed my calls. By a lot.

The instinct, especially when you care about helping someone, is to explain. You want to show them you know what you are doing, so you talk. But on a sales call, the prospect should be doing most of the talking and you should be doing the listening.

 

How Much Should You Talk on a Sales Call?

There is good sales research on this. The numbers I have seen put the seller at roughly 40 to 55 percent of the call, and the prospect gets the rest. Go check the exact figures yourself, because I am giving you the general range, not a citation. What I can tell you for sure is that my own calls lined up with it. I am a pretty good listener, but the calls where I crept over 60 percent talking were the calls I did not close.

As a working rule, aim to talk for less than half of the call.

 

Let the Prospect Talk Their Way Into the Problem

When you ask good questions and then actually let people answer, something useful happens. They hear how big their problem is as they describe it. You do not have to tell them. Questions like these will guide the conversation:

  • How did that make you feel?
  • How has that impacted you?
  • What have you tried that hasn’t worked?

In health and wellness especially, a lot of people have never had anyone give them the space to talk about what they are dealing with. Most of them are happy to.

 

Take Notes in Their Exact Words

While they talk, I take notes. I tell them up front that if they see me looking down or typing, it is because I don’t want to miss anything important. What I am writing down are the specific words they use, because I reflect those words back when I talk about my offer. Your offer lands harder when it sounds like their own description of their problem.

 

Use a Tool That Flags Monologues

One of the worst things you can do on a sales call is go on a monologue. It is easy to slip into a little soapbox lecture without noticing. I use Fathom, which records the call, takes notes, and shows you how much of the call you are talking while it is happening. It flags it when you start to monologue. That live nudge is worth a lot.

 


Mistake #3: Not Getting Curious About Objections

When someone says they need to think about it, or they are not sure, or it sounds like a lot, the instinct is to say “No problem, just let me know.” Don’t. Get curious instead.

Curious does not mean pushy. If someone tells me they are really interested but need to look at their finances or talk to their spouse, I do not push them to decide on the call. I say no problem, and then I set a follow-up expectation (that is mistake #5).

 

What to Say When Someone Says It Sounds Expensive

If the objection is more like “that sounds really expensive,” I say something like this:

I’m not here to pressure you. Did you want to hop off the call now, or do you want to talk a little more about how this could work?

That is another permission point. If it is a hard no, they will say let’s hop off, and that is fine. Neither of you wants to waste time. If they say let’s talk more, you have just been invited to see whether there is a way to make it work.

 

Ask What Is Behind the Objection

Two other lines go a long way: “What makes you say that?” and “I’m curious, where is that coming from?”

Objections are not always no’s. Sometimes the person does not fully understand the offer or the value. Sometimes they are avoiding conflict. Someone says they have to ask their spouse when they have really just decided it is not the right fit and do not want to say so. You can only find out by asking.

The worst thing you can say on a sales call is “just let me know.”

 


Mistake #4: Not Having a Payment Form Open and Ready

I fumbled my pricing on so many calls. Looking back at the transcripts was cringey. I know the pay in full price for HCA, but I have a couple of payment plan options and I kept forgetting the details. I fumbled it over and over until I finally got my act together.

 

Open the Order Form Before the Call

Whichever platform you use, open the order form before the call starts. Have the pay in full option selected in one tab and the payment plan option selected in another. When someone asks about price, you can say “this is the pay in full and these are the payment plan options,” with no scrambling.

It also means you are ready if someone says yes. If they ask when you can start, I say I can take their card now if that works. Some people say yes. Some say they do not have the right card on them, and that is fine. But if someone is open to signing up, I want to be ready to take payment right then. Sometimes I even pre-fill their name, email address, and location so all they have to do is give me the card.

 

Say the Price, Then Stop Talking

This was not even in my notes for the episode, but it might be the most important thing in this whole post. Say the price and then shut the f*** up. My students laugh when I say it, but they remember it.

Pricing and affordability are personal and subjective. What I think is well priced, you might not. Everyone has their own reaction to a price, and they are entitled to it. But quoting a price is awkward, especially when you are new to sales calls, so we want to justify it. We offer a discount. We say it is a really good price. We throw in a bonus. We do anything to fill the space.

Don’t. State the price and let them process it. That may mean sitting through some awkward silence. I won’t let it go on forever. At some point I might ask “How does that sound?” or “What’s coming up for you when I say that?” But wait longer than feels comfortable. Let it be awkward. Sit in it. Have a hot tub in that awkwardness.

 


Mistake #5: Not Setting Follow-Up Expectations

I got this one right on almost all of my calls, but it is the one I see coaches skip most. With a higher-priced offer, a lot of people will not pay on the call, and that is fine. It is normal to talk to a spouse who shares your finances. It is normal to sleep on a decision. I do not pressure anyone. But whenever someone wants to think about it, I create a clear expectation for what happens next.

 

What to Say for a Follow-Up

Okay, Jane, here’s what I’m going to do. I’ll send you a summary of our call and the things I’ll help you with inside HCA. The email will have the pricing options and a link to the overview page. If I don’t hear from you, I’ll follow up with you on Thursday. Does that sound good?

A few details make this work.

  • Tell them when the email is coming. I send mine right after the call. I pull the Fathom transcript, drop it into Claude, and it drafts the follow-up. Later that day or the next morning works too, as long as you say which.
  • Always include a link to your sales page or an overview page so they can dig into the details on their own.
  • If they need more time, say yes. If they ask you to follow up on Friday because their spouse is traveling until then, follow up on Friday.
  • Ask how they want to be followed up with: email, Instagram, whatever it is. Then follow up on that day, by that method.

I usually pre-write the follow-up email and leave it in drafts, with a reminder on my calendar to send it if I have not heard back. I also tell them that if anything comes up before then, they can reply to the email or send me a DM.

 

Keep Control of the Ball

You never want to put the ball in their court. “Just let me know” does exactly that. It leaves them holding the decision, the follow-up, and the awkwardness. When you set the expectation, you keep control of the ball.

 

Follow Up More Than Once

People usually need a decent number of follow-ups before they say yes, and most coaches give up far too early. There is a way to do it that does not feel overwhelming and does not make you feel like you are bothering anyone.

One line I use: “If at any point you decide this is not the right fit, just let me know. If I don’t hear from you, I’m going to keep following up until you essentially tell me to go away.” I say it with a bit of humor. It puts people at ease, gives them an easy way out, and lets you stay in the conversation without guilt.

 


The Sales Call Mistakes Checklist

Run your next call against this list.

  • Did I open with something personal?
  • Did I tell them how the call would go, mention the pitch, and ask “Does that sound good?”
  • Did the prospect do most of the talking?
  • Did I write down their exact words?
  • When I heard an objection, did I get curious instead of saying “just let me know”?
  • Was my payment form open, with pay in full and payment plan ready to go?
  • Did I say the price and then stop talking?
  • If they wanted to think about it, did I set a clear follow-up with a date and a method?

If you can say yes to all eight, and especially to the one about talking less, you are going to be in good shape.

 


Sales Call FAQ

What is a good close rate for sales calls?

The industry standard is about 30 percent. With a solid script that you have learned and practiced, you can expect to close above that. My students often close 50 to 60 percent of their calls, and 90 percent is possible but rare.

 

How much should I talk on a sales call?

Less than half. The research I have seen suggests the seller talks roughly 40 to 55 percent of the call, though you should verify the exact numbers. In my own 50 calls, the ones where I talked more than 60 percent were the ones I did not close.

 

What do I say when a prospect says my offer sounds expensive?

Say you are not there to pressure them, and ask whether they want to hop off the call or talk more about how it could work. Then ask what makes them say that. The goal is to find out whether this is a real no, a misunderstanding about the value, or something else.

 

How soon should I send a follow-up email after a sales call?

Tell the person during the call when you will send it, then send it when you said you would. I send mine right away, but later that day or the next morning works as long as they know when to expect it.

 

Should I pressure someone to decide on the call?

No. It is normal for people to talk to a spouse or take a few days. Instead of pressuring, set a clear follow-up with a date and a method, and keep following up.

 


 

Leave the podcast a 5-star review: https://ratethispodcast.com/wealthy

- Kendra
Share this post:
Keep Reading