This one is straight from Day 1 of my free Nail Your Niche challenge, and it is the training I wish someone had handed me in year two of my health coaching business.

Here is the short version. You have a niche. It is probably not niched enough to work in 2026. The way we niche has changed in the last two years and most coaches are still running a strategy from 2023, which is why you can do everything right and still feel invisible.

I break down the three criteria a problem has to meet before it will ever make you money, why root cause language quietly kills your marketing, and the shift I call identity-based niching. I audit a lot of businesses. Almost nobody has this part in place.

I also tell the story of the cliff I jumped off that ended my skiing career, the seven years of chronic fatigue that followed, and the $10K year that turned into a quarter million once I stopped communicating like a practitioner.

—

Listen to the podcast here

Listen on your preferred podcast platform:

 

---

In This Episode:

 

 

RESOURCES:

---

 

Leave the podcast a 5-star review: https://ratethispodcast.com/wealthy

 

---

 

Your Niche Isn’t Niched Enough: Identity-Based Niching for Health Coaches

You picked a niche. You did the thing everyone told you to do. You stopped saying “I help people feel better” and started saying “I help women in their 40s with fatigue,” and you felt pretty good about it, because that is what niching looked like when you learned it.

 

And then nothing happened.

 

You post. You show up. You talk about what you do. You know your stuff cold, you have the certifications, and the handful of clients you have had are out here telling people you changed their life. And your account still feels like shouting into a stairwell.

 

Here is what I want you to hear before anything else: this is almost never a talent problem. I audit a lot of businesses. Dozens of them. Probably hundreds at this point. The coaches who are stuck are not stuck because they are bad at what they do. They are stuck because their niche was built on advice that expired, and nobody sent them the memo.

 

---

The Advice You Got Was Right in 2023

Niching is not new information. Get specific. Pick an ideal client. Stop trying to help everyone. You have heard it four thousand times and I am not going to make it four thousand and one.

 

The problem is not that you skipped the lesson. The problem is that the market moved and the lesson did not move with it.

 

COVID pushed millions of businesses online that had zero intention of ever being online. It kicked off the content creator revolution, which means there are now people who make a full living producing content and nothing else. On top of that there are more health coaches, more practitioners, more certification programs, and more offers than there have ever been.

 

The average person is now shown somewhere between 6,000 and 10,000 promotional messages a day. A day. That is roughly five times what it was ten years ago.

 

Your brain would liquefy if it actually processed all of that, so it does not. It runs a filter. That filter throws out anything that does not feel like it was built specifically for the person holding the phone.

 

This is the part I really want to land, because it reframes the whole thing. When you feel invisible online, it is almost never because someone looked at your page and thought “ugh, her content sucks, hard pass.” That is not what is happening. What is happening is that they never consciously registered you at all. You got filtered before you got evaluated.

 

And the flip side of all that noise is that your potential clients now have more choice than they have ever had in human history. They do not have to settle for a program that is sort of close to their situation. They can hold out for the one that is exactly for them, exactly their problem, exactly their life. And they do.

 

So the bar moved. A significantly higher level of specificity is required to get noticed now than was required even two years ago. Most coaches I talk to are niching off 2023 information in a 2026 market.

 

---

What Most Coaches Are Actually Selling

Before we get into the niche itself, we have to deal with the thing sitting underneath it.

 

Here is what I see when I ask a coach what they sell. Six sessions. A lab test, or a handful of lab tests. An intake and assessment. A personalized protocol. Weekly check-ins. Chat support in between. Meal plans. A few PDFs.

 

Sometimes there is one version of that. Sometimes there are three tiers of it, an intro one and a middle one and a big one.

 

There is nothing wrong with any of those things. They might be genuinely valuable, and they might be exactly how you get people results. But if that list is your answer to “what do you sell,” you do not have an offer. You have a list of deliverables.

 

A list of deliverables is not positioning. And the instinct everyone has when the thing is not selling, which is to add more to the list, makes it worse, not better. Another PDF is not what is standing between you and a full client roster.

 

I know this because I did it for years.

 

---

The Ten Thousand Dollar Year

I got into this the way most of us do, through my own body falling apart.

 

Fifteen years ago I jumped off a cliff on purpose, because at the time I was chasing a career as a professional skier. I spent summers in forestry, fighting wildfires and planting trees and laying out cut blocks for logging operations, then got laid off every November and skied all winter. I was filming a movie when I blew my knee out. Reconstructive ACL surgery. I was almost 30, which is old for an athlete, and in about one second the life I thought I had was gone.

 

What came after the surgery was seven years of debilitating chronic fatigue and a parade of doctors who could not tell me anything useful. It was the darkest stretch of my life. It also gave me two problems to solve at once: heal myself, and find a new career.

 

So I went down the natural health rabbit hole, found functional health coaching, and thought I had hit the jackpot. I got certified. Then I got a diploma. Then I collected a few more certifications, came out the other side absolutely fired up, and assumed that being good at the work would be enough to build a business.

 

It was not. My professional background was forestry and skiing. Not exactly a crash course in online marketing.

 

I did what I was told to do. I spent months building a beautiful website, launched it, and genuinely believed clients would start appearing. You know what happened. Nothing happened.

 

Eventually I clawed my way to clients by hustling. I sold single sessions by the hour, which meant more money required more clients, more clients required more appointments, and more appointments required more hours parked in front of a laptop. I had traded a 50 hour a week forestry job for a 50 hour a week computer job, except now I did not get five months off and I was making dramatically less money.

 

Two and a half years in, I made just over $10,000 in an entire year. For an enormous amount of effort.

 

So I packaged things up into wellness packages, which was better. I could charge more and work with people longer. But my packages looked exactly like the list above. A number of sessions, some functional testing, a protocol, some resources.

 

And when I tried to explain why anyone should hire me, I used every word my certifications had taught me. Root cause. Functional approach. Holistic healing. HPA axis dysfunction. Nervous system regulation. My model of self care.

 

I thought it sounded impressive. What it actually did was ensure that nobody had the faintest idea what I did for a living.

 

I was communicating like a practitioner instead of like the person trying to buy from a practitioner. That was the entire problem. I did not need a sixth certification. I did not need more stuff in the package. I needed to learn how to describe the value of what I was already doing, in the language of the person on the other side of the screen, so the right human would read it and think “oh, that’s me.”

 

When I finally niched down to one human and one transformation and built a single package around it, I cleared $90,000 the following year. When I learned positioning and messaging properly and applied it to that exact same offer, without changing the offer itself at all, I cleared almost a quarter of a million the year after that.

 

Same work. Same deliverables. Different communication.

 

---

A Profitable Problem Is Chronic

Now let’s build the niche properly, because not all niches make money.

 

A niche has three parts: the human, the problem, and the outcome. The first two carry almost all the weight, so that is where we are going to live.

 

Starting with the problem. For a problem to be worth building a business on, it has to clear three criteria. The first is that it has to be chronic.

 

Chronic just means it happens on a regular basis. That is a little subjective, and it should be. When I had chronic fatigue, there was no minute of any day where I was not tired. It was constant. But someone with brutal menstrual cramps only deals with it a few days a month, and that still counts, because it comes back on a schedule and they know it is coming.

 

What does not count is the one-off. “I had a weird rash three months ago and it never came back” is not a business. That one should be obvious, but people do try.

 

---

A Profitable Problem Is Severe

Second criterion. The problem has to be severe enough that it is genuinely wrecking the person’s quality of life.

 

The cleanest way to understand this is a tension headache versus a migraine.

 

A tension headache can absolutely be chronic. Plenty of people get one most days. But it is not severe, because you can take an ibuprofen and get on with your afternoon. Nobody is hiring a practitioner and running lab work over something an Advil fixes. Maybe they book a couple of sessions with a naturopath at some point. They are not investing real money.

 

A migraine is a completely different animal. I have never had one, but I have friends who do, and from what they describe it is horrific. You cannot function. You cannot work. The Advil does absolutely nothing. And it is not a one-time event, it is happening weekly, or monthly with their cycle.

 

That is the difference between an inconvenience and a problem someone will pay to solve.

 

People do not spend meaningful money on prevention. They spend it on the thing that is actively stealing their life right now. Chronic plus severe is the zone where you find clients who are motivated, ready, and good to work with.

 

---

The Third Criterion Trumps the Other Two

Here is the one almost nobody accounts for, and it will override both of the others. Awareness.

The Four Stages of Awareness

In marketing there are four stages a person can be in.

 

Unaware. They do not know they have the problem.

 

Problem aware. They know they have a problem. They do not know how to fix it.

 

Solution aware. They know a solution exists, but they are not sure which route to take.

 

Product aware. They know about your specific offer.

 

Good marketing moves people through those stages. But you have to pick your entry point, and the entry point you want is problem aware. That is where the money is and that is where the least friction is.

 

Unaware is the hardest, slowest, most expensive person to attract, because before you can sell anything you first have to convince them they have a problem they did not know they had. That is an enormous amount of work to do for free.

 

---

Why Root Cause Language Puts You in Front of Unaware People

Here is how health coaches accidentally end up marketing to unaware people, and it happens constantly.

 

You build your niche around a root cause instead of the symptom, condition, or diagnosis the person actually experiences.

 

Take inflammation. Nobody is sitting on their couch googling how to fix their inflammation. They do not know they have inflammation. Inflammation is the thing underneath the thing. What they know is that their back hurts every single day, or they cannot lose weight, or they are exhausted.

 

Same with blood sugar. Almost nobody is searching for a blood sugar solution. They know they crave sugar at 3pm. They know they crash. They know they have type two diabetes, or that the weight will not budge.

 

Adrenal fatigue, leaky gut, nervous system dysregulation, HPA axis dysfunction, parasites. All real. All underneath. None of them are the words your person uses about their own life.

 

And the kicker: the person does not even have to actually have the problem. They just have to believe they have it. Awareness is the currency, not accuracy.

 

---

What to Target Instead

Straight swaps, root cause on the left, what they actually know on the right:

• They do not know they have metabolic issues. They know they cannot lose weight.
• They do not know they have nervous system dysregulation. They know they are snapping at everyone and cannot control their anger.
• They do not know they have inflammation. They know their back has hurt for two years.
• They do not know they have parasites or leaky gut. They know they are bloated.
• They do not know they have blood sugar imbalances. They know about the weight.
• They do not know they have adrenal fatigue. They know they are exhausted.

 

Notice you still get to treat the root cause. That never changes. You just stop leading with it.

 

---

Diagnoses Work, If They Are Already Diagnosed

I get asked about mold constantly, so let’s use it.

 

Can you niche in mold? Yes. But only if you are targeting people who have already been diagnosed with a mold issue. Those people are problem aware. They know. They are looking.

 

What you cannot do is try to convince people that mold might be behind their symptoms and then sell to them. That is unaware, and it is a losing game.

 

The alternative is to target the most common symptom instead, say chronic fatigue, and simply accept that some of the people you attract will not have mold, because not everyone with fatigue does.

 

Same logic for SIBO, Hashimoto’s, Graves, celiac, rheumatoid arthritis, Crohn’s, eczema. All perfectly good niches, as long as you understand you are meeting people at the point in their journey where a diagnosis already exists. You are not in the business of convincing people to go find one.

 

Which brings up a related trap. “Autoimmune issues” is not a niche. Rheumatoid arthritis, Hashimoto’s, and Graves are three completely different lived experiences with three completely different symptom pictures. Messaging that has to cover all of them ends up covering none of them. Plus, a shocking number of people do not know their condition is autoimmune. I know someone who has had Hashimoto’s for twenty years and only recently asked me, genuinely, whether it counts as an autoimmune disease. People do not have our training. Pick one condition.

 

---

The Problem You Have Lived Is the Easiest One to Sell

This one is not mandatory, but it makes your life enormously easier.

 

If you have personally dealt with the problem, or you are still dealing with it, or someone close to you is, your marketing gets a shortcut. Your story becomes an asset. Your empathy is real instead of researched. And you understand the texture of the problem at a level you cannot get from a textbook.

 

Are there people who are brilliant experts in conditions they have never had? Absolutely. I am fairly confident there are men out there who are excellent menopause practitioners and they are never going to experience it. It can be done. It is just harder.

 

And you do not have to be finished. This is where imposter syndrome eats people alive. They think “who am I to help with this when I have not fully solved it myself.”

 

When I ran my health coaching business, my niche was outdoor enthusiast women in their thirties with chronic fatigue. That was me. And I still had chronic fatigue while I was running that business successfully. I had gone from a one out of ten on energy to about a six. Better, not fixed. And I said so, publicly, constantly.

 

People loved it. Transparency about where you actually are beats a polished finished-journey story almost every time. Nobody is asking you to be healed. They want to know what you are doing and whether it is working.

 

---

Identity-Based Niching

Okay. Here is the actual shift, and it is the one I almost never see in place when I audit a business.

 

The problem half of your niche has mattered since the dawn of internet time. That part is not new. What changed in the last couple of years is the human half.

 

A niche used to look like “I help women in their 40s with weight loss.” That was enough. It is not anymore.

 

A Demographic Is Not an Identity

“Women in their 40s” is the single most requested target market I hear, and it tells us almost nothing.

 

A woman in her forties could be a single corporate professional. She could be a divorced empty nester whose kids left home. She could have teenagers. She could be a stay at home mom. She could be a brand new mom.

 

I am 42 with a two year old. I had a baby late. My Tuesday looks nothing like the Tuesday of a woman my age whose kids moved out five years ago. Nothing. Not the schedule, not the stress, not the sleep, not the money, not what is realistic for her to change about her diet this week.

 

Gender plus age is a demographic. It says nothing about a lived experience, and lived experience is the thing people buy.

 

The Map Their Day Test

Here is a test you can run on yourself in about sixty seconds.

 

Can you map out your person’s entire day, from the moment they open their eyes to the moment they go to bed?

 

If you can, you have an identity. If you cannot, you have a demographic, and you are going to keep struggling.

 

You genuinely cannot do this exercise for “women in their thirties.” There is no single answer. You can absolutely do it for “nine to five working moms of toddlers in their thirties.”

 

Phrases That Are Not Identities

When I ask coaches to define their human, this is the list I get back. All of these fail:

 

• High achieving woman. High achieving in what. It describes a vibe, not a life.
• Woman 40 plus. Gender and age. Demographic.
• Busy moms. Name a mom who is not busy. Name a human who is not busy. Also, what kind of mom. A mom of an infant and a mom of a 40 year old man are both moms.
• Heart centered. I say this with love. What does that mean.
• Health conscious. We wish. Plenty of people who describe themselves that way, you look at their week and it is not what is happening.
• Woman in perimenopause. This is the big one, and it is not an identity. It is also not a problem. Perimenopause is a life phase. You can absolutely help people in it, but a woman in perimenopause can be a single corporate executive, a new mom, a mom of a teenager, or a digital nomad, and those are four completely different lives.

Why the Same Program Has to Be Built Differently

Identity is not just a marketing exercise. It changes what you actually build.

 

Say you have a fatigue program. Now build it for new moms in their first year postpartum. Everything revolves around the baby. The only realistic window to do anything for themselves is during nap time, and that window is unpredictable and short. Sleep is not a variable you get to optimize. Cooking is a fantasy some days.

 

Now build the same fatigue program for retired seniors. Wide open schedule. Nobody else in the house. Completely different physical starting point. Completely different motivation.

 

Same problem. Two programs that should look nothing alike.

 

That is why specificity matters, and it loops right back to the filter. Nobody has to settle for a general fatigue program when there is one designed for their exact life.

 

Real identities look like: new moms, divorcees, current athletes, former athletes, teachers, stay at home moms, empty nesters, parents of teens, toddler dads, digital nomads, nine to five corporate professionals, self-employed moms of young children.

 

And you do not need to specify gender if you do not want to. New parents works fine as an identity and includes everyone. What you cannot skip is the daily experience.

 

---

Your Method Is Not Your Niche

This is the distinction that saves people the most grief, so I want to be very clear about it.

 

Your method is how you help people. Lab testing. HTMA. Reiki. Intuitive eating. Macro tracking. Acupuncture. Counseling. Trauma coaching. Plant-based nutrition. Blood sugar balancing.

 

All of that belongs in your offer. It is how you practice. It is not your niche and it does not belong in your niche statement.

 

I teach hair tissue mineral analysis, and I had someone tell me recently that now that she offers HTMA, her entire positioning has to change. It does not. HTMA is the vehicle. The person in your audience does not wake up wanting a mineral panel. They wake up exhausted.

 

The reason this matters so much is that a niche statement has exactly one job, and it is a three second yes or no. It is the first thing on your website. It is the first thing in your bio. Someone has about three seconds to decide whether to stick around.

 

Think of it as a billboard on the highway. You get maybe three to five seconds, and you are not even looking straight at it, because you are also trying not to drive into a ditch. If you put a dense paragraph on a billboard, you have wasted your money. Nobody is going to pull over to finish reading.

 

Nobody has ever read a niche statement and bought a program. That is not what it is for. They read it, think “huh, interesting,” follow you, and then your content does the actual work of showing them your philosophy, your method, and whether you are the right fit.

 

So when you catch yourself trying to cram in the method because you want to look different from every other weight loss coach, stop. That difference lands later, and it lands harder, when it shows up in your content instead of in a run-on sentence in your bio.

 

What goes in: the human identity and the problem. If you have space, the outcome. That is it.

 

One exception worth naming. Sometimes the method is the differentiator because the audience is actively comparing it to an alternative they do not want. If someone comes to you for fine lines and wrinkles and you address it by correcting mineral deficiencies, then “without injectables” earns its spot, because Botox is the thing they are weighing you against. That is not method-stuffing. That is a genuine point of differentiation the buyer already cares about.

 

---

Pain Points Beat Outcomes

A question I get constantly: should I focus on the positive outcome instead of the problem?

 

No. Lead with the problem.

 

Pain point marketing outperforms outcome-based marketing. There is a mountain of research on it and it matches everything I have seen in a decade and a half of running businesses. People are naturally oriented toward the negative. That is just how the machine works.

 

This does not mean you never speak to the outcome. Painting the dream is a real and necessary part of good marketing. It just is not where you open. Do not try to fight human psychology on this one. You will lose.

 

---

Your Niche Is a Marketing Decision, Not a Practice Decision

Last thing, and it is the thing that unsticks most people who have been agonizing over this for months.

 

Your niche is your marketing. It is not how you practice.

 

Inside your offer, you do all of it. Every tool you have. If you niche in bloating, and the gut-brain axis means some of your clients need nervous system work, you do the nervous system work. It goes in the program. It just does not go in the bio.

 

That means choosing is far less scary than it feels. It is a business decision, it is reversible, and it does not limit how you actually help a human being sitting in front of you.

 

You can switch. I have switched three times. I started with women with hormone imbalance, which was not niched enough. I moved to outdoor enthusiast women in their thirties with chronic fatigue. Then I became a business coach and an HTMA educator.

 

The one thing to understand is that every niche is a separate business. I have two now and they both require their own marketing, their own content, their own audience. There is overlap, but they are not one thing. So pick one, build it, and expand later if you want to. Trying to build two at once is how people end up with neither.

 

---

Common Questions About Niching as a Health Coach

Can I have more than one niche?

Not at the start. Every niche is effectively a separate business with its own audience, content, and messaging. If you have three profitable problems you could target, that is genuinely good news, it just means you have to sequence them instead of running them at once. Pick the one you have the most personal experience with, build it, and expand later.

 

What if I can help almost anyone?

Most of us can, and that is exactly why this is hard. But think about the skincare product that claims to fix every skin condition. Nobody believes it. When I got melasma during pregnancy I did not buy the do-everything cream, I bought the one for melasma. Being able to help everyone and marketing to everyone are two different things, and only one of them gets you clients.

 

Is my niche the same as my differentiator?

No. Your niche is the human plus the problem. Your differentiator is why your method works better than the standard advice. Both matter. Only one of them belongs in your bio.

 

What if I have not personally solved the problem myself?

You do not need to have solved it. You need to be honest about where you are. I ran a successful chronic fatigue business while I still had chronic fatigue, and I said so out loud the entire time. People trust that far more than a tidy before and after.

 

How specific is too specific?

In an online business, almost nobody has ever been too specific. The failure mode runs overwhelmingly in the other direction. If you genuinely worry the market is too small, do the research rather than guessing. Look up how many people are diagnosed with the thing in the region you are marketing to. You want that number comfortably over a million.

 

Does this apply to an in-person practice?

Less so. Brick and mortar is a different game, because you are only competing with the handful of practitioners inside a few square miles, and people physically walk past you. You can build a very successful in-person practice without niching hard, though niching still helps. Online is where it becomes non-negotiable, because there is no storefront and nobody is strolling by.